R C Bhargava, Venu Srinivasan face off with govt on auto GST charge

R C Bhargava, Venu Srinivasan face off with govt on auto GST charge

The federal government and captains of India’s vehicle (auto) business have been at variance at an business occasion, additional widening the hole in consensus on discount of tax on passenger vehicles and two-wheelers.

With Income Secretary Tarun Bajaj within the viewers, two auto business veterans – R C Bhargava, chairman of India’s largest carmaker Maruti Suzuki, and Venu Srinivasan, chairman of TVS Motor Firm – questioned the federal government’s intent to assist the sector.

Calling for a discount in taxes, they puzzled if the contribution of the auto business in the direction of India’s development was being recognised by policymakers and have been perturbed at vehicles being thought-about a luxurious solely the wealthy can afford.

“There have been a variety of statements made on the significance of the auto business. However when it comes to concrete motion, which might reverse the decline in pattern, I have not seen any on the bottom. I’m afraid phrases do not get us very a lot when it comes to additional gross sales,” mentioned Bhargava.

It was seemingly directed at Bajaj, who, as head of the Division of Income, workouts management associated to direct and oblique tax of the union.

Trade foyer group Society of Indian Vehicle Producers (Siam) mentioned the general auto volumes in 2020-21 (FY21) within the home market pushed the business again by six years. Passenger car volumes in FY21 have been the bottom since 2015-16; two-wheeler volumes the bottom since 2014-15.

Gross sales of economic autos in FY21 have been the worst in 11 years; for three-wheelers, they have been the bottom in 19 years. Siam blamed the elevated value of possession as a result of excessive items and providers tax (GST) and a hike in highway tax because the killjoys.

Srinivasan echoed Bhargava, saying whereas India’s two-wheeler business is the biggest on the planet and largely thought-about a typical man’s mode of transport, the GST charges are just like these for luxurious vehicles.

“The worth of the moped has gone up 45-50 per cent. The GST on two-wheelers is similar as a luxury-level product. Is the auto sector being recognised for what it has contributed to the atmosphere, to income, and to overseas alternate earnings? That’s the query R C Bhargava has raised,” mentioned Srinivasan.

ALSO READ: AAR guidelines 18% GST on e-voucher merchants, on plea by advertising providers agency

When his flip got here, Bajaj requested if taxation was the rationale why business development was impeded. “I wish to perceive, earlier than GST got here, what was the taxation construction in giant auto markets? Was the taxation construction any lesser? I believe it might need been just a little increased. We won’t lower taxes with out figuring out whether or not that can really result in a corresponding enhance in auto gross sales,” he mentioned.

He identified that the gross sales of sport utility autos (SUVs) are rising when gross sales in different segments will not be. “I’m eager to grasp the rationale behind the autumn in numbers after 2017-18 for a sector that promised excessive development a number of years again,” mentioned Bajaj, including that if taxes are diminished, it’ll power the federal government to borrow extra. This could have a unfavorable affect on the macroeconomy. “A 360-degree view have to be taken earlier than making a choice,” mentioned Bajaj.

Bhargava retorted saying the expansion of SUV as a metric will not be the proper manner since most patrons favor entry-level fashions whose costs have gone up by Rs 45,000-50,000 as a result of new security and emission norms, rising insurance coverage, and highway tax.

“These incomes higher have graduated to an SUV. However for a big part, like the customer of an Alto or WagonR, a rise of Rs 45-50,000 is big. On the decrease finish, most can barely afford a automobile. Please maintain the affordability consider thoughts,” he cautioned.

That is the second time {that a} distinction in opinion between the business and the federal government has arisen. Final 12 months, Shekar Viswanathan, former vice-chairman of Toyota Kirloskar Motor, had mentioned the federal government retains taxes on vehicles and motorbikes so excessive that his firm finds it troublesome to broaden.

However the finance ministry countered saying auto firms ought to cut back royalty funds to folks overseas as a substitute of searching for tax cuts.